So, your little bundle of joy has finally arrived—or is about to—and now it’s time to dive into the world of baby toys! 


If you’re feeling a bit overwhelmed by the sheer number of options, don’t worry—you’re not alone. Choosing the right toys for your new baby doesn’t have to be a guessing game.


In this guide, we’ll talk about curating a toy collection that’s not just cute (although that’s important too), but also stimulating, safe, and developmental.

1. Start with the Basics: Soft and Sensory Toys


Babies are all about discovering the world through touch, sound, and sight. So, when you’re curating your collection, start with soft toys that are perfect for little hands and curious mouths. Enter the world of Little Dutch’s Sensory Balls . These little cuties are made from soft, baby-friendly fabric and feature gentle sounds that are perfect for your new-born's developing senses. The rattle encourages grasping and helps babies learn cause and effect (i.e., grab the toy, it  does something - how fun!).

Shop Little Dutch sensory balls

Pro tip: Babies love bright colors and contrasting patterns, so don’t be afraid to pick toys that have vibrant hues and eye-catching designs—like Little Dutch’s adorable, striped rattle or their pastel animal rattle collection.

2. Engage with Fun, Functional Play Mats


A play mat isn’t just a cushy surface for tummy time—it’s an interactive experience! A good play mat, like the Little Dutch Play Mat , can stimulate your baby’s senses with textures, colors, and fun patterns. 


Plus, it provides a cozy spot for your little one to roll, kick, and explore their world. Look for one with soft, tactile elements like crinkly parts, squeaky toys, or mirrors—these are all perfect for engaging your baby’s curiosity. 


It doubles as a comfy space for baby to practice those early motor skills!


Little Dutch - Playmat - Playfaire

Pro tip: Play mats are great for babies as they grow because they encourage physical development, like tummy time and crawling. Little Dutch’s play mats are not only functional but also look great in any nursery with their neutral, pastel colors and sweet, calming designs.

3. Introduce Textures and Tactile Exploration


Texture is your baby’s best friend when it comes to exploring their surroundings. Tiny fingers love to touch and explore the different sensations that come with various materials. 


Little Dutch’s Soft Books are perfect for introducing your baby to this world of tactile exploration. These books are soft, colorful, and full of fun fabrics that will keep your baby entertained while also helping to develop their fine motor skills.


Plus, the simple designs and characters are ideal for introducing your baby to shapes, colors, and even the basics of storytelling. It’s never too early to start reading (and letting them chew on the pages a little, of course!).


Shop little dutch soft books

4. Musical Toys for Little Ears


We know babies love sounds—whether it’s a lullaby or the rattle of a toy, sound is a major way they explore their world. So, why not incorporate some musical toys into the mix? 


Musical Toys are perfect for babies who are starting to develop their listening skills. These toys are soft, gentle, and make sweet sounds—perfect for keeping your baby entertained while also nurturing their sense of hearing and cause-and-effect understanding.


These toys are also great as your baby grows a little older and starts to develop motor skills, as they’ll love tugging on the strings to hear the melody play!


Little Dutch Rain Rattle - Playfaire

Pro Tip: Try incorporating a consistent lullaby or sound before bedtime as part of a calming routine. Babies thrive on consistency, so using the same song or soothing sound each night can help signal to your little one that it’s time to wind down and get ready for sleep. Plus, it can become a comforting, familiar part of their bedtime ritual as they grow!

5. SPLASHING Bath Time Fun


Bath time can be one of the most fun and playful parts of your baby’s day, and the right bath toys can make it even more enjoyable! Baby bath toys are perfect for turning a splashy routine into an adventure. 


Look for soft, squeezable toys that are easy for little hands to hold, like rubber ducks, squirt toys, or floating boats. 


These toys not only entertain but also help develop your baby's hand-eye coordination as they learn to grab, squeeze, and splash. Plus, bath time toys with bright colors or gentle squeaks can stimulate your baby’s senses, making it a multi-sensory experience. 


Just make sure to choose bath toys that are easy to clean and dry quickly to prevent any mold or bacteria buildup. Bath time is about more than just getting clean—it’s a chance to play and bond while your baby enjoys the water!

Pro Tip: To keep bath time fun and hygienic, be sure to regularly clean your baby’s bath toys by rinsing them with warm water and soap after each use. You can also squeeze out any water from toys that squirt to prevent mold buildup. For extra peace of mind, store the toys in a mesh bag or bath toy organizer that allows air to flow, helping them dry quickly and stay fresh for every splashy adventure!

6. Toys that Grow with Baby


While your new-born might not be playing with stacking rings just yet, it’s nice to think ahead and choose a few toys that will grow with your baby. Some toys, like soft blocks or activity gyms, can be used for tummy time and later for sitting and stacking. Choosing toys that evolve with your baby’s developmental stages means your collection will last beyond just the new-born phase, saving you money and reducing clutter.

7. Big Cuddles for little ones


A first teddy bear is a classic and cherished companion that holds a special place in both your baby's heart and their toy collection. Soft, cuddly, and full of comfort, a teddy bear can quickly become a beloved friend during those early years. Not only does it provide your baby with a source of warmth and security, but it can also play an important role in nurturing emotional development. Whether it’s for snuggling during naps or serving as a comfort object during bedtime, the first teddy bear is often a source of gentle companionship. Look for one that’s hypoallergenic and machine washable, as babies tend to drool or spit up during those first months, and you’ll want to keep it clean for your little one. This timeless toy can stay with them for years, becoming a treasured keepsake as they grow older.



Pro Tip : If you’re thinking of giving your baby a first teddy bear, consider getting one that has a removable, washable cover or is easily cleaned. Since babies love to hug and chew on their soft companions, it's always a good idea to have a backup or two—just in case one gets lost in the laundry! Plus, you can rotate them to keep that soft, “new bear” feel fresh for your little one.

Conclusion


Building a toy collection for your newborn doesn’t need to be overwhelming. With careful selection, you can create a collection that enhances their development and brings joy. A balance of tactile, auditory, and visual toys will provide the right foundation for their growth.

Focus on sensory toys that engage sight, sound, and touch.

Choose soft, washable, and non-toxic materials to ensure safety.

Opt for versatile toys that grow with your child’s developmental stages.

May 05, 2025 — Jessie Arnold